• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Whalley Pizza

**Our Story: Whalley Pizza**

Nestled in the heart of New Haven, Whalley Pizza boasts a rich culinary heritage, specializing in Greek-inspired pizzas that have garnered a loyal following. Diners rave about its generous portions and exceptional flavors, making it a go-to spot for both lunch and dinner. With a welcoming atmosphere, Whalley Pizza is perfect for groups, families, and even takeout cravings. The menu extends beyond pizza, featuring delicious breakfast options and satisfying sandwiches. Each visit promises not only delightful dishes but also friendly service from dedicated staff, ensuring that every meal is memorable. Discover why Whalley Pizza is a beloved local gem!

Whalley Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Ansh Dhelia
Ansh Dhelia

The pizza here was a very pleasant surprise. There was a lot of quantity for only 12. The small option will be enough food for most people. Great pizza.

Marviano “HIMKARDASHIAN” LeeMartinez
Marviano “HIMKARDASHIAN” LeeMartinez

Grilled chicken over rice is always a hit been eating it for almost 10 yrs now when I first met my husband he introduced me to their food staff is always polite the men work hard and they dont disappoint Marvin sent ya ...

Richard Carpenos
Richard Carpenos

It aint easy to offer Greek pizza in the pizza capitol of the world but this place has carved out a slice of title! Ive had dozens of pies from Whalley Pizza and theyve all been consistently incredible! Its the best Greek in the state ...

Stephanie T
Stephanie T

Hope is amazing!!! My coworker put me on to the spot and you can have a salad for days!

Britt Snider
Britt Snider

Wow. The food is so fantastic and the lady working the register was so darn nice. I came in during a dinner rush and she was very quick taking orders at the counter and getting orders to their people. The tables and booths are clean, and I ...

Kate Kosior
Kate Kosior

Yum! Ordered a pepperoni pizza and it smelled absolutely divine on the car ride home. It tasted fantastic super garlicy and crispy thin pan style pizza crust. Definitely going to get this again! I was not disappointed.

In God I trust
In God I trust

Well what can I say !?! 20 for a big large sausage and cheese pizza ! YAY , last time I had half broccoli half sausage and the pizza was still good and still in the 20 range ! The pizza and the box is huge ! I travel from fair haven area ...

Jillian Felice
Jillian Felice

Whalley Pizza is the bomb in has been the bomb for at least 20 years I say that because thats how long Ive been going there to eat I started going there when I first moved to the neighborhood and I took my kids kids now they go and take their kids is kids and now I take my grandkids but yes I love it its the neighborhood go to spot

Location

  • Whalley Pizza
    350 Whalley Ave, New Haven, CT 06511 Hotline: (203) 789-8100

Welcome to Whalley Pizza, a hidden gem nestled on Whalley Avenue in New Haven, Connecticut. This unclaimed eatery stands out in the vibrant world of pizza, offering not just traditional pies, but a delightful array of breakfast and brunch options that make it a must-visit for food enthusiasts.

At Whalley Pizza, the experience goes beyond just taking a seat. With a welcoming atmosphere that includes outdoor seating and bike parking, this place is ideal for groups and families alike. Whether you're looking to grab a slice for lunch or settle in for dinner, you'll find plenty of options to satisfy your cravings.

  • Takeout and Reservations: Perfect for those on the go or anyone looking to enjoy a meal in the comfort of their home.
  • Vegetarian Options: A commendable selection of vegetarian dishes ensures that everyone can find something to enjoy.
  • Kid-Friendly: The menu features plenty of choices that appeal to younger palates, making it a great dining spot for families.
  • Affordable Prices: Signature sandwiches such as the Beef Burger and Cheeseburger are generously portioned and reasonably priced, with sandwiches starting as low as $4.25.
  • Greek Pizza:** Renowned for its Greek pizza, Whalley Pizza has garnered praise from locals for consistently delivering delicious flavors and quality ingredients, proving it can stand tall amidst New Haven's famous pizza culture.

What truly sets Whalley Pizza apart is the warmth of its staff. Reviewers often highlight the polite and friendly service that enhances the dining experience. Ansh Dhelia remarked, "The pizza here was a very pleasant surprise," noting the generous portion sizes that can satisfy most appetites. Similarly, Marviano "HIMKARDASHIAN" LeeMartinez shared his long-standing affection for the grilled chicken over rice, emphasizing the commitment of the hardworking staff.

The reviews speak for themselves; visitors have lauded everything from the cleanliness of the dining area to the efficiency during busy hours. The inviting environment, coupled with delicious food and keen attention to customer service, makes Whalley Pizza an exceptional choice for your next meal.

So, if you're in New Haven and on the lookout for a delicious pizza experience or a satisfying brunch, make sure to stop by Whalley Pizza at 350 Whalley Ave. With a phone number of (203) 789-8100, don’t hesitate to call ahead for takeout or reservations. Come and discover why Whalley Pizza is quickly becoming a favorite among locals!